Michelle Hay

Training - works every day

0161 298 1040

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • Home
  • Food Safety
    • CIEH Supervising Food Safety Catering Level 3
    • Catering Health and Safety
    • Food Safety Level 2
    • HACCP Principles Food Safety Level 2
    • Food Allergen Awareness Level 2
    • Food Safety Level 1
  • Health & Safety
    • Health and Safety for Directors and Managers
    • CIEH Supervising Health and Safety Level 3 Award
    • Manual Handling Train the Trainer
    • Health & Safety Level 2
    • Fire Marshal Training
    • DSE Workstation Training for Office Workers
    • Manual Handling of Objects
    • Fire Safety Awareness
    • Risk Assessment
    • COSHH Safety
    • Health and Safety Level 1
  • First Aid
    • Emergency First Aid at Work
    • First Aid at Work
  • Consultancy
    • Health and Safety Support
    • Fire Risk Assessment
    • Food Safety Management System Audit
    • Catering Kitchen Design
  • Contact
  • News
  • About
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Privacy Policy
    • Book a Course
    • Workshops
  • Testimonials
  • Online Training
You are here: Home / Health and safety / Training vs Fines. New guidelines may help you decide

Training vs Fines. New guidelines may help you decide

21/01/2016 by Michelle Hay Leave a Comment

From the 1st February this year, we will start to see the effects of the latest and long overdue changes to the sentencing and penalties handed down to organisations for serious health and safety failings, corporate manslaughter and food safety and hygiene offences. So if you think you can’t afford the training, can you afford the new fines? Training vs fines? New guidelines may help you decide.

justice-picThe Sentencing Council’s guidance will apply from 1st February regardless of the date of the offence and Judges now have a tiered penalties framework to guide them. The framework is based on the size of the organisation, its’ turnover, the level of harm risked and the culpability established.

Currently, fines for health and safety offences resulting in death should not normally exceed £100,000 and not less than £500,000 for corporate manslaughter. However, these figures seem like loose change compared to what’s about to start happening in the UK courts.

For the most serious health and safety offences, (not just fatalities), we are likely to see fines of up to £10 million if the organisation’s turnover is greater than £50 million.  This sliding scale comes right down to micro-organisations (less than £2 million) being punished with fines of up to £450,000. For a large organisation convicted of corporate manslaughter, they may face a fine of up to £20 million. Businesses will now have to submit three years accounts to help the courts decide on the level of fine.

In order to decide on the level of fine, the courts will also take into account other factors, such as past convictions and poor health and safety practices. Although, co-operation, self-reporting and acceptance of responsibility may help the organisation, the fines for failures will still be light years away from where they are now.

One of the activities that sparks the most debate when I am training health and safety in the workplace is ‘how much were the fines’. Several example cases of past failings are presented to the groups and they have to guess what the actual amount of the fines given were. Out of eight cases, no group has ever got more than two fines correct.

What this demonstrates, is that the current judicial system is all over the place. Speculation as to what mood the Judge was in, how many other failings have happened and where you live have been put forward as to the reason for the lack of consistency.

VauxhallWith all of this in mind, I wonder how the new guidance would have affected the Vauxhall Motors trial in the case of Alan Heard. Mr Heard was crushed by machinery in his work area in 2011, where he had worked for over 42 years ‘man and boy’. He died three weeks later in hospital. The court heard that Vauxhall had made changes to one of the entrances into the area and a doorway had been created through a wall at the back of the paint unit. The changes meant that access was allowed without power being cut to dangerous machinery.

A risk assessment had been carried out following the change (10 years earlier), and the findings, that the change in the doorway meant that the light sensor no longer cut out machinery if people walked past, was ignored.  Vauxhall were fined just £150,000. I suspect that from February, a similar case might attract a fine of up to £20 million.

If it can be proved that an organisation has received prior warning and was aware of certain hazards and then had ignored those warnings and as a result been negligent, then the courts will surely penalise those individuals and organisations responsible for their ignorance.

Culpability* is the key word here. If a company fails in its duty under the Health and Safety Act etc. 1974, and it is proven to have ignored near misses, warnings and/or advice from various sources, the court will not look too kindly on this and fine accordingly.

Many business owners and leaders don’t readily grasp the consequences of not complying with health and safety legislation and indeed, don’t understand their duties in law. But the law considers this and states that organisations must enlist expert help in these matters.

The message here is loud and clear. If you could do more to safeguard the health, safety, welfare and the life of your employees, then you should. Do it now! Don’t fall foul of the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974, It could cost you dearly, even your whole business.

*Culpability generally implies that an act performed is wrong, but does not involve any evil intent. It has limited significance in Criminal Law, except in cases of reckless homicide in which a person acts negligently or demonstrates disregard for life, which results in a person’s death. In general, culpability is used to mean reprehensible rather than grossly negligent behaviour. Culpable conduct may be wrong but it is not necessarily criminal.

Michelle Hay Training Limited provides health and safety consultancy, support, advice and training to businesses throughout the Northwest area. Register and come along to the FREE monthly health and safety workshop for senior managers, specifically aimed at helping CEOs, MDs and H&S reps understand their duties in law. Call 0161 298 1040 or email michelle@michellehay.com

 

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)

Filed Under: Health and safety, Help and Advice, HSE.gov.uk, News, Risk Assessment, Training Tagged With: Health and safety, Injuries at work, Managing Safety, Training

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Online Training Courses

Fire Safety Health and Safety Training online course

Our effective online training courses are a practical way to deliver training for maximum learning in minimum time.

Find out more

loading Loading

    • Michelle was very engaging. Using film, leaflets, quizzes and more. The course was excellent.

      —C Poynter

    • The food hygiene course was excellent. I like the way Michelle taught us and she gave us lots of knowledge. The photos and visual actives were great.

      —M Aljeraisi

    • The course was good. The visuals and exercises helped to take in the information.

      —E Rimmer

    • I liked this fire safety course. It was informative and gave good points on risk assessment. I will make sure that procedures are followed correctly.

      —M Bonney

    • Overall the course was very good. The practical practice and videos were helpful. I learnt what to do in a fire and about fire hazards.

      —D Newton

    • The course was excellent and I liked the activities and testing the knowledge throughout.

      —E Rimmer

    • Excellent training, interesting with lots of examples. I learnt about temp control and not mixing food and allergens.

      —D Newton

    • The course was excellent and I liked the interactive nature that it was delivered. I will think about the bigger picture and pick up things properly and plan my moves.

      —C Guest

    • The course made me think rather than listen and I liked that. I learnt how to deal with moving and handling things at work and home and to think and plan actions first.

      —A Raffi

    • I liked Michelle’s natural style of training. The activities were good and I felt included.

      —E Rimmer

    • The course was excellent. I liked the practical side, filling out the forms, learning to assess risk for myself.

      —D Newton

    • The pace of the course was good for me. I liked that Michelle spoke clearly and enjoyed the UV hand washing task.

      —D Hill

    • Michelle was polite and spoke clearly. The course was excellent and I learnt all about temps, rules and regs.

      —T Pilling

    • I liked the activities and inclusion. I learned a lot about HACCP, temperatures and hand washing

      —J Ward

    • The food safety course was good and I liked learning about bacteria and how to wash my hands properly

      —S Higginbottom

    • The course was very good. Michelle is a very good teacher. I like the theory and practical examples.

      —S Hewitt

    • The course was very good use of my time as it helps me with my job. Michelle was well spoken and clear in the instructions given.

      —Steven

    • I found a lot of information useful and it made me think a lot more about my surroundings at work. Michelle spoke clearly and concise, made it fun and interesting and was helpful.

      —K Rowley

    • It was useful on how to lift and carry properly. I liked the fun activities, working with other groups and more understanding of it all. I had fun.

      —N Williams

    • All of the training was interesting and will benefit my job. Michelle kept us all motivated with the activities and changing groups.

      —M Ryan

    • The training made me think about the best way to lift things. I liked the involvement with others, the tests and examples.

      —B Morton

    • Michelle was most useful as she told me everything I need to know. It was brilliant in every way.

      —D Sherlock

    • I liked the the way the course was delivered in a relaxed manner, but all areas were covered in depth. The fire risk assessment part was excellent.

      —M Wilkins

    • Made me think about my surroundings and how to ensure the safety of my colleagues. I will definitely use that I have learnt.

      —A Hazeldine

    • The training was very thorough and answered questions I had. I will take a lot more care when lifting. Thanks Michelle.

      —J Monks

    • The course was informative without being boring. I enjoyed the interaction. I learnt how to identify hazards and work more safely.

      —V Slinn

    • I thought the course was good. Very detailed and informative and included a mixture of visual and textual content.

      —M Macdonald

    • I liked the practical element and the video part of the training best.

      —R Spencer

    • Excellent course. It was interactive, with videos rather than just a slideshow.

      —S Mitchell

    • I liked the visual aids during the training. I learnt about the correct method of carrying out manual handling tasks.

      —L Huber

    • A relaxed atmosphere and pleasantly interactive.

      —D Hosty

    • The course was excellent. I thought the presentation was interesting and informative.

      —K Ogston

    • The training was clear and well paced with good use of the visual aids and quizzes. Michelle was knowledgeable and helpful

      —G Hogg

    • The course was excellent and the I gained and retained knowledge in safe working methods and awareness

      —G Wild

    • Michelle’s teaching methods were excellent and I will pay attention to hazards and potential risks in the office

      —R Fleming

    • I liked the fact that the methods the method the information being given varied in delivery which kept the course fresh and engaging.

      —A Brown

    • I have a more indepth knowledge of health and safety and I liked the engaging activities too. I now know how to risk assess.

      —J Lee

    • The simplicity of the delivery and the use of a variety of learning techniques suited me best. I learned the key legislation behind health and safety workplace requirements.

      —R Haskin

    • It was interesting and useful. Can be put into practice now. Michelle is a good teacher.

      —S Frith

    • I thought the training was fun, enjoyable and very informative. I enjoyed the practical lifting.

      —W Merridith

    • The training was informative and had a variety of ways to learn. The visual aids and quizzes were excellent.

      —L Muir

    • The group exercises were the best and I have a more indepth knowledge of health and safety and risk assessments now.

      —L higgins

    • I liked the fact the training made me more aware of the risks of the tasks I do daily. I will make sure that I will not be lazy and lift objects in the correct way.

      —L Jones

    • The training was easy to understand and very informative. Very well presented.

      —A Dodd

    • Overall the course was excellent.  I liked the personal touch and the trainer was very friendly. I improved my knowledge where there were gaps.

      —D Reece

    • I liked that the training was conducted on site and examples were relevant to our site. We weren’t just sat down and that the training included movement to keep us alert.

      —We’re Moving Relocation Services

    • The training was very clear, appropriate and easily explained.

      —T McCarthy

    • We went through everything that we needed to learn about. Michelle was very good. She made it easy to understand things.

      —J Turner

    • It was very good and was useful that I know many things about my work. Everything was explained well in a good and simple way.

      —A Abouseley

    • The course was very interesting. Michelle brought in her own personal experiences to help relate to examples.

      —S McDonald

    • Michelle was friendly, spoke clearly, was happy, and exiting.

      —K Milburn

    • The course was really useful and Michelle used both practical and theory methods to deliver the training. It’s made me realise all about food safety awareness.

      —P Bottomley

    • The questions and interactions were the best and I learnt a lot more about food hygiene.

      —A Brownlee

    • I liked that you could stop and ask questions relevant to our own business.

      —J Sweeting

    • It was genuinely very good, interactive, not boring. I learnt a lot of stuff.

      —M Bradley

    • Michelle was very knowledgable, very approachable, well prepared and the course was both enjoyable and useful.

      —J Catton

    • Michelle has an excellent field of knowledge, all questions were answered and she managed to make a boring subject interesting.

      —B Fisher

    • Good knowledge of all subjects, very supportive and I was not bored at all. Very good.

      —S Cole

    • Very knowledgable on the subject material, well prepared and I learned a lot about the risks

      —S Miles

    • Michelle was great at explaining everything. There was no waiting for anything, very well prepared.

      —C Graham

    • Michelle training was very good, a job well done and ‘what went well?’ Everything!

      —D Hilton

    • Trainer had extemely good knowledge. Good examples and visuals.

      —S Clarence

    • A good level of involvement and a good atmosphere. Not too heavy, but still educating.

      —J Harrison

    • I thought the trainer, Michelle, was very good, I learnt a lot and it was very enjoyable.

      —J Taylor

    • The training was well delivered and good interaction. The pace was just right.

      —F Duffey

    • The training was spot on. We were all involved.

      —G Pearson

    • The trainer’s subject knowledge was excellent. She was really approachable and supportive

      —D Bateson

    • Trainer very knowledgeable, friendly and made you feel at ease. Course was interesting and useful.

      —S Ashworth

    • Very well presented, making it an enjoyable and helpful experience

      —A Evans

    • Trainer was very knowledgeable, approachable and well prepared. Found the course very useful and enjoyable

      —J Catton

    • Trainer was very approachable, good pace and very informative

      —J Halpin

    • The trainer’s delivery was very clear and more than adequate. All aspects were positive. Very good trainer.

      —M Donoghue

    • Really impressed. The course was very detailed and Michelle was very helpful and clear.

      —L Rowley

    • It helped me realise that there is more to just lifting boxes. You’ve got to assess the weight and much more…

      —A Littler

    • Eye-opening. The training itself was very easy to understand

      —A Rogers

    • Informal atmosphere and interaction with fellow learners was great.

      —M Kirby

    • Helpful tutor, thanks. excellent and smiley face all day.

      —M Akgun

    • Knowledgable trainer, educational. Making me more aware of the work environment. Good tutor.

      —J Whalley

    • I liked not being treated like an idiot when I asked a question and being treated as an individual

      —D Newman

    • We have asked Michelle to run a few courses for us and have had some very positive feedback. We look forward to working with Michelle in the future.

      —M Cooke

    • Michelle has great focus on both detail and on the analysis of how to best meet an employees needs

      —A Hall

    • I would not hesitate in nominating Michelle as a trainer to all levels of staff, based on her work ethic and approachable manner

      —R Winstanley

    • Michelle has an outstanding ability to create a friendly, relaxed learning/training environment

      —A Popham

    • I learnt a lot about being safe and thoughtful in the workplace

      —S Cheetham

    • The training was presented well, very informative and enjoyable sessions

      —S Hughes

    • I learnt to risk assess and be more aware of my working environment… gaining knowledge which will help me personally as well as others

      —L Melles

    • I received a lot of knowledge on mine and my employers responsibilities in the workplace. This included facts, statistics, visual aids and group discussions

      —S Kelly

    • I liked the group activities and everything was very clearly explained

      —D Ward

    • It opened my eyes to things you see everyday but take for granted. The course was very informative

      —G Nixon

    • It was very informative, with good information and very indepth

      —G Phillips

    • I liked the experience brought to good use by the trainer through examples

      —M Gill

    • Relevant to the work environment with interactive exercises.

      —J Clues

    • I liked the group work, team discussion. Very in depth.

      —N Scholes

    • Very informative and flows at a good pace

      —D Nixon

    • That was fun training. I enjoyed it.

      —Lou

    • I think it is very helpful, the content of the course

      —F Guimaraes

    • I really enjoyed the training, Michelle was fun to work with and is very good at her job.

      —G James

    • Found the training to be more involved than the last course I attended. More practical training and very enjoyable.

      —A Johnson

    • I enjoyed our training, we had a lovely day with our trainer. We had actual knowledge of suitable things to know

      —E Savage

    • Very enjoyable, fun, easy to understand

      —S Kirby

    • A very comprehensive covering of the subject in the time allowed.

      —D Wilkinson

    • Comprehensive, concentrated, clear.

      —E Timney

    • Very interesting and informative    

      —J McDonagh

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Recent Posts

  • Is Permanently Working from Home Healthy and Safe?
  • Working from Home During the Corona Virus Crisis
  • Back to the Future with Emma – DSE Workstation Design
  • Health and Safety Fines and Prosecutions
  • HSE Welding Safety Changes and Guidance
  • How to keep cool and look good during a heatwave
  • Protect people, property and stock from fire
  • Fire safety checks for employers and building owners

What people are saying…

  • Dra Safety on Why do office staff need health and safety training?
  • Elen Williams on Feedback is always welcome
  • Michelle Hay on Feedback is always welcome
  • Bill Walker on Feedback is always welcome
  • Michelle Hay on Feedback is always welcome

Find Me Around The Web

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Twitter

Categories

Archives

Copyright © 2023 Michelle Hay. Site Built by Zed1.com. Hosted by WP Hosting